Judge warns of possible legal challenges arising from 'idiotic' lack of a second courtroom in Roscommon Town
Roscommon Courthouse located at Racecourse Road, Roscommon. Pic: Gerard O'Loughlin
The 'idiotic' lack of a second courtroom in Roscommon Town could lead to legal challenges, Judge James Faughnan has warned.
Currently the county town’s district court sittings have to be moved to Castlerea while Roscommon Circuit Court is sitting, resulting in six or seven relocations over the past year.
The historic courthouse in Roscommon Town has been closed by the Courts Service since December 2022 for health and safety reasons, and major concern has been expressed about its increasingly dilapidated condition and its future. The sittings were moved to the former dance hall building on the Racecourse Road.
Earlier this year, it was announced that funding amounted to a total of €350,000 and has been allocated to the historic courthouse for "preparatory works".
Speaking at a recent sitting of Roscommon District Court in Castlerea, Judge Faughnan said that it was “idiocy” for the state to spend €1.5 million on providing a temporary courthouse with only a single courtroom.
He said that people in the Roscommon Town area were being discommoded by the lack of court facilities. This was forcing people, who were often at their lowest ebb, to travel to Castlerea, he continued. For some people, travelling was not possible, resulting in bench warrants being issued for them.
“This could be challenged I feel,” the judge continued, condemning the situation as “highly unsatisfactory”. “The relevant people need to get working on it.” He said it would not cost much to connect an annex to the temporary courtroom site, something he had suggested two years ago. Moving the court and the cases to Castlerea resulted in thousands, and possibly hundreds of thousands, of euro in costs to the state, he said. Judge Faughnan said that the closure of the old courthouse was a temporary measure, and that he would continue to highlight the issue.
“We can’t sleep walk into it (the permanent closure),” he said. “I have already emailed the Courts Service about this and been duly ignored.”
He was informed by President of the Roscommon Bar Association, Seán Mahon, that there was “no progress whatsoever” on reopening the old courthouse, adding that he did not disagree with the judge’s comments.
Mr Mahon said that the county’s solicitors had been given “tepid assurances” about the future of the old court building. He added that the funding announced did not relate to the building’s reinstatement.
Mr Mahon also informed the court that practitioners were initially told that two courtrooms would be provided in the temporary building, but these plans were “changed surreptitiously”.

