Calves were allowed to die without veterinary intervention, inspector tells farmer’s trial

During an interview the farmer disputed that a shed had been poorly bedded, stating  animals were on bark mulch.
Calves were allowed to die without veterinary intervention, inspector tells farmer’s trial

Roscommon Circuit Court heard details of animals welfare issues.

Two calves found dead on a Roscommon farm were allowed to die in a cold, slatted shed without veterinary intervention, an inspector with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine has told a jury.

The trial at Roscommon Circuit Court, of Mayo farmer Sean Coughlan and Coughlan Farming Ltd also heard that Mr Coughlan disputed findings about the care of his animals and said restrictions on his herd prevented him from moving cattle off the farm.

Mr Coughlan, of Cum, Laharane, Ballina, County Mayo, and the company, for which he is sole director, have pleaded not guilty to a combined total of 78 charges connected to the welfare of animals on a farm at Laragan, Elphin, County Roscommon in 2022.

Mr Coughlan is represented personally by Bernard Madden SC and Patrick O’Sullivan BL, instructed by Kamal Vaid, while Coughlan Farming Ltd is represented by Fergal McMorrow BL, instructed by Matthew Kenny.

Continuing his evidence to Sean O’Quiggley BL, instructed by State Solicitor for County Roscommon Kieran Madigan, Superintending Veterinary Inspector Arthur O’Connor outlined his examination of veterinary records relating to the farm.

Mr O’Connor, of the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, said he obtained practice records and prescriptions from veterinary practitioner John McCourt, following inspections at the farm on November 23rd and 29th, 2022.

Around the dates of the inspections, the records showed the euthanasia of a cow on November 29th, and an attendance concerning lame cows the following day.

However, he could find no record of veterinary intervention for the two calves found dead during the earlier visit on November 23rd.

“Those animals died without a veterinary practitioner being called to get treatment for them,” he said, adding that he formed the opinion that the calves had been allowed to die in a cold, slatted shed without intervention. At a minimum, they should have been moved out of the cold, wet shed, he said.

Mr O’Connor also said he could find no reference up to December 15th, 2022, to a group of poorly calves identified during the inspection being examined or treated.

A memorandum of cautioned interview with Mr Coughlan on February 28th, 2023, was read to the jury. When asked when the two calves had died, Mr Coughlan said: “that day, maybe”.

When further asked how they died, he said he couldn’t recall, but suggested pneumonia as there had been an issue with pneumonia on the farm. Asked whether treatment records existed, he said he didn’t know as he didn’t have the records in front of him.

He suggested the dead calves had been left on the slats because the person working on the farm “wasn’t competent” to remove them with a loader, and was awaiting Mr Coughlan’s return.

He was also asked about a number of decomposing animal remains and bones discovered on his farm, including the remains of at least three dead calves found on a heap of dung.

“That’s where we leave animals for the knackery. They must’ve been left behind,” he said.

He denied that it was the farm’s practice to leave calves to decompose on a dung pit, saying animals were brought there so the knackery would know where to collect them.

Mr O’Connor further outlined concerns about a group of “lame to severely lame” cows house with 21 young, untagged calves.

Some cows had shoes glued to their feet, while others had raw areas following hoof paring. One was bleeding.

He said this was not overly unusual to see in a large dairy herd, where an inspection could take place shortly after treatment. His concern was that the cows were not on soft bedding, but standing in dirty conditions or on hard, cold concrete.

The bedding was inappropriate from both a disease and welfare perspective, he added, referring to unhygienic and faecally contaminated bedding.

During his interview, Mr Coughlan disputed that the shed had been poorly bedded, stating the animals were on bark mulch.

“I don’t accept those findings. I changed the bedding that day,” he said, adding that he had sent a photograph of the replacement bedding through WhatsApp.

Mr O’Connor told the jury that, although the farm had substantial facilities, animal numbers exceeded what its sheds could accommodate.

“From a housing point of view, the housing was completely inadequate for the number of cows being milked,” he said.

An animal welfare notice was issued following the November 29th inspection. A subsequent visit found that several requirements had not been met.

Bedding in the shed Mr Coughlan had been instructed to clean remained wet and contaminated, though not to the same extent as before.

There were also 187 tagged but unregistered animals that had not subsequently been registered, while Mr Coughlan had not accounted for 93 animals recorded as being on the farms but not found during the inspections.

Asked about those animals in interview, Mr Coughlan said many had been grazing at the time of the inspection. He also said he could not comply with a requirement to reduce the herd because the department had locked his herd number and he could not move animals.

He said nine staff were on the payroll that month but declined to name them, alleging that they had asked him not to provide their names because of bullying by department officials. He declined to identify the officials concerned.

Under cross-examination, Mr Madden put it to Mr O’Connor that the veterinary records showed Mr McCourt attending the farm every month, sometimes several times. In fact, he said, there were ten visits one February alone, and the same number in March of the same year.

Mr O’Connor said ten engagements in February or March wouldn’t be a huge number for a herd calving 500 calves. He couldn’t say each entry represented a visit, as some could relate to prescriptions, he said.

Mr Madden also questioned whether the imposition of a Roscommon herd number in June 2021 had prevented Mr Coughlan from moving cattle between his Roscommon, Clare and Mayo farms, as he had previously done without issue.

Mr O’Connor said the movements were suspended when he became involved with the case, but farmers could move animals once they complied with the requirements. His understanding was that the suspension was related to failure to carry out a TB test under the Roscommon herd number.

He said Mr Coughlan disputed that herd number, but he did not consider the dispute relevant to the treatment of the animals.

The trial continues on Wednesday.

*Published as part of the Court Reporting Scheme

More in this section