Farmer’s dispute with department was ‘wild good chase’ for welfare investigation, inspector tells trial

The trial is being heard before Judge Kenneth Connolly and a jury at Roscommon Circuit Court
Farmer’s dispute with department was ‘wild good chase’ for welfare investigation, inspector tells trial

The trial at Roscommon Circuit Court is entering its second week.

An inspector investigating alleged animal welfare offences on a County Roscommon farm has rejected suggestions that he should have pursued the farmer’s earlier dispute with the Department of Agriculture, describing it as a “wild goose chase”.

The jury trial of Mayo farmer Sean Coughlan and Coughlan Farming Ltd also heard challenges to the inspector’s findings about dead calves, bedding and contamination of milking equipment.

Mr Coughlan, of Cum, Lahardane, Ballina, County Mayo, and the company, for which he is sole director, have pleaded not guilty to a combined total of 78 charges connected to the welfare of animals on a farm at Laragan, Elphin, County Roscommon.

The trial is being heard before Judge Kenneth Connolly and a jury at Roscommon Circuit Court and is entering its second week.

Mr Coughlan is represented personally by Bernard Madden SC and Patrick O’Sullivan BL, instructed by Kamal Vaid, while Coughlan Farming Ltd is represented by Fergal McMorrow BL, instructed by Matthew Kenny.

Cross-examining Superintending Veterinary Inspector with the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine Arthur O’Connor, Mr McMorrow questioned his investigation of Mr Coughlan’s dispute with the department over herd registration and restrictions on animal movements.

Mr McMorrow said his instructions were that a departmental official had taken Mr Coughlan’s calving book in early 2021 and that it remained in the department’s possession.

Mr O’Connor said he did not know whether the department still held the book. He regarded the dispute as an administrative issue which was not pertinent to his investigation.

Mr McMorrow put it to him that Mr Coughlan had sought assistance from various departmental offices and had been refused help.

“I’d be shocked if that was the case,” Mr O’Connor replied.

Asked why he had not obtained witness statements about those interactions, he said he did not consider them relevant to the alleged offences.

He did not see how events a year and a half or two years earlier were relevant to two calves being found dead in a shed on November 23rd, 2022, or a cow lying in unhygienic conditions on November 29th, he said.

Mr McMorrow referred to Mr Coughlan’s account that departmental officials had told him he could not move animals because his herd was suspended.

Mr O’Connor said facilities were available to farmers whose animals were in peril because of overcrowding or other issues.

“It’s not a fact that a person can’t move animals off their herd when the herd is suspended. In my mind, this was a wild goose chase for me,” he said.

In questions arising from cross-examination, prosecuting counsel Sean O’Quiggley BL, instructed by State Solicitor for County Roscommon Kieran Madigan, asked whether the contention that retention of the record book prevented movements and led to overcrowding had been investigated.

Mr O’Connor said it had been investigated by the department and considered, but had no real relevance to the ongoing issues he observed in November 2022 and afterwards.

Earlier, Mr Madden questioned whether disease could explain symptoms among the animals, referring to Mycoplasma Bovis, which was an issue on the farm at the time. Mycoplasma is difficult to recognise, Mr Madden said, and symptoms can include lameness and pneumonia.

Mr O’Connor said he had not been told the animals had that disease. He wasn’t saying they didn’t have it, but stressed that lameness could have many causes.

The chronically lame cows he saw did not have pneumonia, he said, while pneumonia was present in younger stock. His concern was not the lameness or pneumonia, he said, but rather the conditions in which the animals were being kept, which he said were negligent of their welfare.

Mr Madden also questioned why inspectors visited on November 23rd when a letter had given notice of an inspection on November 29th. Mr O’Connor said the earlier visit was intended to view the facilities and make contact with Mr Coughlan, but inspectors were entitled to enter farm premises without calling first, he said.

Mr McMorrow in his cross-examination, challenged the inspector on his statement that two dead calves found in a slatted shed on the farm had their eyes so sunken that they appeared to no longer be visible.

He suggested that the animals could have died that day and had their eyes eaten by birds. Mr O’Connor accepted that scavenging could happen quickly and that carcasses were exposed to scavengers. However, there would be telltale signs which he had not observed.

He rejected the suggestion that the calves might not have been dead long, maintaining his assessment that they had been dead, possibly for more than two days.

Mr McMorrow also challenged his description of bedding, saying Mr Coughlan’s account was that the animals were bedded on bark mulch. Mr O’Connor confirmed he had not taken samples of the bedding, relying instead on photographs, video and his experience in the area.

“I think I can determine when I’m walking through bark mulch and when I’m walking through cow dung,” he said.

Mr McMorrow suggested activity during the inspection accounted for fresh dung in the collecting yard and milking parlour.

Mr O’Connor accepted unfamiliar people could cause cows to defecate excessively, but said caked contamination on equipment was not from that morning.

He disagreed that other milking clusters looked clean, saying he could see contamination on every cluster visible in the photograph.

He accepted there had been washing of the clusters that morning, but said they remained below the standard he expected. He also agreed the pit floor was clean.

The jury subsequently heard from veterinary inspector James Casey, who outlined follow-up visits and communications with Mr Coughlan.

Mr Casey said a notice concerning an overdue TB test was served in October 2022. Copies sent by registered post to addresses associated with Mr Coughlan were returned, with postal markings including “not called for” and “refused”.

A further animal welfare notice was served on December 7th, following the November inspection. Mr Casey said Mr Coughlan telephoned two days later to discuss it and indicated he would endeavour to comply.

Some requirements had a deadline of December 12th, while others were to be met by January 3rd, 2023.

During a December 14th visit, Mr Casey said he found a weak calf lying on concrete slats which required urgent attention. A cow previously identified as very lame was now down and appeared dehydrated and thing.

There was evidence that animals had received veterinary attention, including prescriptions. However, he had not received documentation showing that a vet had examined the calves’ respiratory problems as required.

He was satisfied that the collecting yard had been cleaned and receipts demonstrated that animal remains had been properly disposed of.

The following day, Mr Coughlan sent videos showing animals receiving water and a calf in a straw-bedded shed under an infrared lamp. Mr Coughlan also stated that the cow about which Mr Casey had expressed concern had been put down.

On December 20th, Mr Casey found the calf in a comfortable shed and was satisfied with its accommodation. He subsequently told Mr Coughlan that overall he found things satisfactory during that visit, while continuing to seek veterinary documentation. Mr Coughlan later sent plans for managing lame cows and calves.

A January 12th visit found compliance with some requirements, including hygiene and removal of remains, but other matters remained outstanding. These included animal identification and registration, an account of 93 animals not found during inspections, calving records and evidence of staff attending an animal husbandry course.

Mr Casey also described lame cows requiring attention and areas where animals had no water available. Mr Coughlan said the water supply would be restored shortly.

On January 20th, Mr Casey told Mr Coughlan that a local officer would be made available to help resolve herd discrepancies and correct animal movement records.

A written response from Mr Coughlan contained positive engagement and impressive proposals concerning staffing and housing, Mr Casey said, but did not go far enough to establish compliance with the notice.

He described the calf management plan as a “very worthy aspiration”, saying the measures would improve calf health if followed.

The trial continues on Thursday.

*Published as part of the Courts Reporting Scheme.

More in this section